The American League bullys it's way to an All Star DH
Thought for the evening:

When I was no more than 8-years-old someone tried to explain to me the reason that pitching in the American League don't bat. It took about ten minutes of me repeatedly asking why before I finally got the, "that's just what they do!" When the logic behind a rule doesn't make sense to an 8-year-old, it might be time to rethink the rule.

Let's be honest, the DH is about as legit as letting that one kid who owned the best football in the neighborhood play all time quarterback during pick up games. Just because that kid owns the best toys, he gets to bully his way into making everyone play by whatever rules he wants.

The American League just bullied it's way into getting the National League to play by it's rules. It has been reported that starting this year, and continuing for future seasons, the DH will be used at all All Star games.

Now I get that the American League is more than the favorite child of Major League Baseball and they are going to get their way when the two leagues are playing in their yard, but this will be true even in National League parks. You have to play by the bully's rules even in your own yard. Sad.

Let me get this straight. In an effort to make this game seem more competitive and less like the lukewarm scrimmage is typically is, you attempt to take away the little bit of home field advantage a team might have? Smart. Any chance we could cut the scoreboard off too and just let everyone bat once per inning? Afterwards you can all walk over to Pizza Hut together. We'll reserve that little party room, order a couple pitchers of Kool-Aid, slam some cheese pizza and goldfish, and give every guy a tiny trophy and a completion certificate.



What are the pros and cons for doing this? Pros: Who wants to see a pitcher hit in an All-star game? Like that in NL parks no DH means that 14 AL starting DHs don't get on the ballot. Cons: Tradition.

And how exactly is NL given a home field advantage because of no DH? For 26-28 players it isn't even their home park. Also, there isn't even a reference as how the 14 AL owners "bullied" 16 NL owners into voting this through. Its because they didn't. A MLB exec committee did.
Forget tradition, position players and hitters made the big leagues because they could hit. Pitchers made the big leagues because they could pitch. Stick to that! DH should be used all the time.

Especially in the All-Star game.
How does choosing to make both leagues play by one league's rules not get that league some sort of advantage? Now granted bullied was an over exaggeration, but I think baseball caters to the AL and by allowing pitchers who never bat in the regular season to avoid in in the All Star game they are given them an edge. Now its not a huge one, but still an edge.

My point was more that if baseball wants to make this one "count" and make it more like a regular game and less of an exhibition, then why take out any competitive advantages at all? Then again, why force every team to have a player in the game. Seems to be getting closer and closer to a scrimmage, which is fine, but just don't tell me it counts then.

Of course I also wonder why it is ridiculous to have a pitcher bat, but that's the whole DH debate that has and will go on forever.

Comments :
Name :
          
Email :
URL :
Validation :

(Enter the code listed above to validate your request)
Comments :